Very Important. Please go to the magazine website to enjoy our journalism in the magazine. The newsletter is just our bugle, to tell you that there is a new handcrafted feature, review or interview for you to enjoy.
The Sliding Doors Review, By Our Film-Mad Editor, AJ, Alison Jane Reid.
Reader, have you ever thought about how our lives are shaped by chance encounters, split second timing, the conversation we put off and the train we did or didn't catch? Sliding Doors is an irresistible jewel of a British rom com that explores that question with drama, a very British sense of humour, fine acting and music that defines the late nineties from Dido to Jamioquai, Aimee Mann and The Space Monkeys.
But more than that, Sliding Doors is a poem to London town, to genuine love, to second chances, to the London Tube, to twinkling ice cream coloured pink bridges across the Thames and to meeting the love of your life on a train, the tube or in a hospital lift. Anything can happen and isn't that the thrill of life, writes The Luminaries journalist Alison Jane Reid?
Sliding Doors stars Gwyneth Paltrow, John Hannah and John Lynch, with Lynch playing the very worst type of paramour. A sponger, an idler and secret shagger who for the sake of comedy, has no moral compass at all.
The lightness and joby in this film comes from Paltrow and Hannah who possess the kind of chemistry and genuine rapture that makes a film linger on in the imagination and prompts you to ask what if, what if? What if our lives can change or be over in a heartbeat? Doesn't that make it even more important to live utterly in the present, one day at a time?
Love what you've read so far?
Tip our Editor Alison Jane to continue reading or become a paid supporter. Join our magazine as a paid patron here. Support AJ and The Luminaries Magazine.
Read On
Sliding Doors is up, way up, in the canon of quirky films including Four Weddings and a Funeral, Notting Hill, Gregory's Girl, The Holiday and When Harry Met Sally, as rom com classic films that never date, with authentic, well-craftd film writing, witty one liners, superb ensemble acting and scenes that have become cultural touchstones.
Peter Howitt's debut film is also optimistic and funny, despite the tragedy and drama and it's a life-affirming, nineties, culture rush, must-see film that hasn't been ruined by bad writing, corporate interfence or too much budget. It's a great film for anyone who is a Londoner, or who aspires to be.
I never tire of revisiting this perfect jewel of a late nineties rom com directed by Liverpool actor turned director, Peter Howitt and it is our Luminary Magazine film of the week, currenty streaming on Netflix.
You can also buy second hand DVDs of the film to watch whenever you like from Ebay, Oxfam and World of Books.
Remember the star of eighties soap Bread? Yes, Peter Howitt was Joey in Bread. He of the unruly, dirty blond hair and quite the eighties hearthrob. Sliding Doors was his first feature film and it was a hit that has become a classic of the genre. Howitt also has a small cameo in the film as a cheeky man who chats up Helen in the cafe where she works.
The story presents two different versions of what happens to Gwyneth Paltrow, a smart twenty something Calvin Klein wearing pr girl on the morning she gets fired. Two different versions of Helen's day unfold; one where she catches the tube train and one where she doesn't with very different outcomes.
Not withstanding, the effortless way the film simulataneously weaves two different versions of what happens to Paltrow's Helen, I love that Sliding Doors is a film that speaks to me as a woman. I have lived the London life, as a newspaper and magazine journalist, dashing up and down Piccadilly and the Kings Rd on the number 19 bus to discuss interviews and fashion stories and work with pr companies. I've fallen in out of love, madly, and had my heart broken to smithereens on the Mile of Style, Regent Street. I also fell for my own Scotsman at the British Library, only for it to take far too long to find out he is a genius at dates, but a disaster zone at love, marriage, happiness and showing up for everyday life. Being a champion and good at stargazing, Italian restaurants, playing rock guitar and kissing and classical mythology just isn't enough, right?
The difference is that James is the kind of man who shows up for the days of disaster and heartbreak. He's not boring either and cute. That soft, lilting Scottish voice could disarm Helen of Troy.
What we women want is a man who is there for the ordinary, mundane events in life, such as picking up an earing or buying us a milkshake, not just for the dizzy, star-crossed highlights. That is James in Sliding Doors, apart from his tragic mistake not tell Helen he is separated from his wife and getting divorced.
Sliding Doors is one of my favorite London rom comes. More than anything it is a film about London and Londoners from the pink Albert Bridge, where Helen goes to think, the prettiest Bridge across the Thames - to Bertorelli's Italian cafe restaurant on Charlotte Street, Fat Boys Diner and the path along the Thames at Hammersmith. The latter is where Londoner's go to promenade, while away a few hours sitting outside a riverside pub and watching the oarsmen go by as they practice for the celebrated boat race.
The Thrill of Seeing Your London On the Big Screen
These are my London haunts and they will always be. I like seeing them on the big screen. There is something thrilling about seeing the places you love and where your own life has unfolded on film.
Paltrow is very gamine and looks so young in Sliding Doors. It is one of her best roles, because there are no gimmicks, no Hollywood razzmatazz and no brain dead script. Have you noticed how recent and current scripts for Netflix films and dramas are obsessed with sex and so over the top and sometimes plain hysterical? This isn't entertainment, it is torture and car crash TV. Great film and drama is about authentic, believable characters and the quality of the story. Sliding Doors is a quintessentially British film, with Paltrow as an honororary Londoner, down to the joke from Monty Python. If you are not a Monty Python fan it won't make any sense. Watch Python and then you will get it.
Maybe, Paltrow should have been portrayed as an American pr girl who has moved to London. Either way, she is fantastic as Helen, apart from her clipped RP British accent which at times verges on a New York twang version of a nineteen fifties RP British accent for the BBC. Never mind, Paltrow is so good as Helen, that I can forget about the accent.
She's the poster girl for all of us who are trying to negotiate life in a big, restless city, from the joy of best friends, as in Helen's trusty wing girl, Anna, played by Zara Turner with just the right mix of grit and unconditional BF love - to running into the man we want to marry, paying the rent and starting our own business.
Calvin Klein and Fashion That Defined the Nineties Girl
Paltrow's gorgeous Calvin Klein nineties wardrobe also reflects her aspirations and confidence. The long, flowing maxi coat and sharp suits are all about power dressing and the intricate, blonde pixie crop became a star in its own right, with women asking for the Gwyneth.
John Hannah, Four Weddings and a Funeral is funny, raw, honest and very affecting as the handsome Scotsman with the lilting accent, who falls for Helen in both parallel storylines. In the first version, Helen prizes open the tube door, meets James, begins a connection and arrives home to find her boyfriend en flagrante with Lydia. In the other version, Helen misses the train, gets mugged and doesn't catch her snake of a boyfriend in bed with another woman, brilliantly played by Lynch, who wins the worst, dastardly boyfriend gold medal.
Lynch, who resembles a male whippet is happy for Helen to keep him, while she works two jobs and he gets to stay home, not write his novel and shag the scarily intense Lydia. Anyone think that Jean Tripplehorn would have been a very good stand in for Glenn Close in Fatal Attraction?
The comedy comes from Lynch's remarkable self interest and the fact that he is a morality free zone, as his friend and confident Russell declares down the pub.
Of course, I hated the ending where Helen finds real love with James Hammerton only to have it brutally cut short when she is hit by a speeding van and dies from serious internal injuries in James's arms. This is inspired by Howitt's own experience of coming close to being hit by a car after a meeting in Charing Cross. This near miss was the premise for the story at the heart of the film.
Being an eternal romantic, I prefer the second ending. I like Helen and James's meet cute in the lift at the hospital after she survives the shock of finding out her cheating, useless boyfriend had made both her and Lydia pregnant and she has lost the baby after falling down the stairs. Now, it is time for a new life with a Monty Python-loving Scotsman who gets her in both dimensions. Now that is my idea of an optimistic, life-affirming and hopeful new beginning, because anything can happen in a heartbeat and suddenly your life is on a different track with a man who loves Monty Python and thinks you are his dream girl, no Spanish Inquisition necessary.
The End.
The Luminaries Magazine/ Alison Jane Reid Copyright Alison Jane Reid. All Rights in All Formats Reserved. No Ai use or Scraping Without Payment Or Written Permission.
Alison Jane Reid has spent her entire grown up life interviewing and writing about cultural icons for a quarter of a century. She is an editor, author, cultural commentator and loves fashion, movies, baking, hiking, dancing and slow everything.
Join our free range magazine Tribe and Come to Our First Slow Foodie and Movie Magazine Gala in Late May/June 2026.
Tip AJ for this Sliding Doors Review or become a supporter and Patron for more slow, thoughtful, handcrafted journalism. Join The Luminaries Magazine Tribe
Join The Luminaries Magazine Tribe
